You have already reviewed this item. Your previous verdict (saved at 2026-06-24T16:42:46.202214+00:00) was satisfied. Submitting again will save a new entry that overrides it (the previous one is kept in the CSV history).
Case op04 ·
evaluated model GeminiAI ·
judges ClaudeAI, GeminiAI, OpenAI
Selection reason: stratified_random
Understanding point
Blowfish
Code snippet · op04/code1.txt
cipher *__userpurge mlw_decrypt_payload_with_block_cipher@<eax>(
DWORD *a1@<eax>,
cipher *cipher,
BYTE *key,
size_t keyLen)
{
int m; // ebx MAPDST
DWORD *s; // ecx
_DWORD *srcForS; // eax
char *keyPtr; // ecx
int k; // eax
int n; // esi MAPDST
DWORD *p; // edi MAPDST
unsigned int i; // ebx
int j; // ebx
unsigned int blockdata_1_; // ecx MAPDST
char keyCopy[56]; // [esp+10h] [ebp-4Ch] BYREF
unsigned int blockdata[2]; // [esp+48h] [ebp-14h] BYREF
DWORD *(*S)[256]; // [esp+50h] [ebp-Ch]
DWORD *P; // [esp+54h] [ebp-8h]
int remaining; // [esp+68h] [ebp+Ch]
int BoxesLeft; // [esp+68h] [ebp+Ch]
DWORD *(*BoxPtr)[256]; // [esp+6Ch] [ebp+10h]
cipher->unknown_field_0 = *a1;
cipher->unknown_field_4 = a1[1];
cipher->unknown_field_8 = *a1;
cipher->unknown_field_C = a1[1];
S = (DWORD *(*)[256])cipher->S;
memset(cipher->S, 0, sizeof(cipher->S));
if ( keyLen )
{
if ( keyLen > 56 )
keyLen = 56;
}
else
{
keyLen = 1;
}
m = 0;
memcpy(keyCopy, key, keyLen);
P = cipher->P;
qmemcpy(cipher->P, &HARDCODED_BUFFER_72, sizeof(cipher->P));
s = (DWORD *)S;
srcForS = &C2_RESPONSE_PAYLOAD;
n = 4;
do
{
m = 256;
do
{
*s++ = *srcForS++ ^ 0xB103F154;
--m;
}
while ( m );
--n;
}
while ( n );
p = P;
keyPtr = keyCopy;
remaining = 18;
do
{
k = 0;
n = 4;
do
{
++m;
--n;
k = (unsigned __int8)*keyPtr++ | (k << 8);
if ( m == keyLen )
{
m = 0;
keyPtr = keyCopy;
}
}
while ( n );
*p++ ^= k ^ 0xB103F154;
--remaining;
}
while ( remaining );
p = P;
blockdata[0] = 0;
blockdata[1] = 0;
// initialize P array using the key
for ( i = 0; i < 18; i += 2 )
{
blowfish::round(cipher, blockdata);
blockdata_1_ = blockdata[1];
*p = blockdata[0];
p[1] = blockdata_1_;
p += 2;
}
BoxPtr = S;
BoxesLeft = 4;
do
{
p = (DWORD *)BoxPtr;
for ( j = 0; j < 256; j += 2 )
{
blowfish::round(cipher, blockdata);
blockdata_1_ = blockdata[1];
*p = blockdata[0];
p[1] = blockdata_1_;
p += 2;
}
++BoxPtr;
--BoxesLeft;
}
while ( BoxesLeft );
return cipher;
}
Evaluated model output (what the LLM said about the code) · op04/result_GeminiAI1.txt
Here's a static analysis of the provided code snippet:
---
### 1. Functionality Description
The function `mlw_decrypt_payload_with_block_cipher` is responsible for initializing the internal state (P-array and S-boxes) of a Blowfish cipher structure. This process is commonly known as the **key schedule** for the Blowfish algorithm.
Here's a step-by-step breakdown:
1. **Initial State Setup**: It initializes four `unknown_field`s within the `cipher` structure using values from the `a1` parameter, likely setting an initial vector (IV) or a starting state.
2. **Key Handling**: The input `key` is copied into a local buffer `keyCopy`. Its length (`keyLen`) is capped at 56 bytes; if `keyLen` is 0, it defaults to 1. This aligns with Blowfish's key length requirements (up to 448 bits or 56 bytes).
3. **P-array Initialization (Hardcoded)**: The `cipher->P` array (which is 18 `DWORD`s long, consistent with Blowfish's P-array) is initially populated with values from a global/static buffer named `HARDCODED_BUFFER_72`.
4. **S-box Initialization (Hardcoded & XORed)**: The `cipher->S` (S-boxes, four 256-entry `DWORD` arrays) are initialized. Each `DWORD` in the S-boxes is populated from another global/static buffer named `C2_RESPONSE_PAYLOAD` and then XORed with the constant `0xB103F154`.
5. **P-array Keying (First Pass)**: The P-array entries are further modified. The input `key` is processed in 4-byte chunks (wrapping around if the key is shorter). Each P-array entry is XORed with a key chunk and then with the constant `0xB103F154`.
6. **Blowfish Key Schedule Execution**: This is the core part.
* A 64-bit block (`blockdata`) is initialized to zero.
* The `blowfish::round` function is repeatedly called.
* The output of each `blowfish::round` operation (which is an 8-byte block) is used to update two `DWORD`s in the P-array. This process iterates 9 times to fill the 18 `DWORD`s of the P-array.
* After the P-array is fully updated, the same process is applied to the S-boxes. For each of the four S-boxes, `blowfish::round` is called 128 times, and its output updates two `DWORD`s in the current S-box.
7. **Return Value**: The function returns the initialized `cipher` structure, which is now ready for actual encryption or decryption operations using the Blowfish algorithm.
In essence, this function sets up the Blowfish cipher's internal tables (P-array and S-boxes) based on a provided key and several hardcoded initial values. Despite the function name suggesting decryption, its primary role is key schedule generation.
### 2. Well-known Algorithms
* **Blowfish Block Cipher**: The code implements the key schedule for the Blowfish symmetric block cipher. This is evident from:
* The explicit call to `blowfish::round`.
* The structure of the P-array (18 `DWORD`s) and S-boxes (four 256-entry `DWORD` arrays).
* The iterative process of updating the P-array and S-boxes by encrypting a zero block and using the output, which is a hallmark of the Blowfish key schedule.
* The key length handling (up to 56 bytes).
### 3. Indicators of Compromise (IOCs)
* **Hardcoded Buffers/Constants:**
* `HARDCODED_BUFFER_72`: A global/static buffer used to initialize the Blowfish P-array. Its specific contents are an IOC.
* `C2_RESPONSE_PAYLOAD`: A global/static buffer used to initialize the Blowfish S-boxes. Its specific contents are an IOC. The name suggests it might contain data related to Command and Control (C2) communication, possibly an embedded encrypted payload or initial S-box values derived from C2 data.
* `0xB103F154`: A hardcoded XOR constant used during the initialization of both P-array and S-boxes.
* **No direct file paths, IP addresses, domains, registry keys, or commands/scripts are present in this specific code snippet.** The IOCs are cryptographic constants and embedded data.
### 4. MITRE ATT&CK Techniques
* **T1573.001 - Encrypted Channel: Symmetric Cryptography**
* **Justification:** The code explicitly implements the key schedule for the Blowfish symmetric block cipher. This cipher is used to establish an encrypted channel or encrypt data. The function name `mlw_decrypt_payload_with_block_cipher` (even if this specific function is key setup) strongly implies that Blowfish will be used for encryption/decryption of data, likely for Command and Control (C2) communication or payload protection.
* **Evidence:** `blowfish::round` function call, initialization of P-array and S-boxes, `key` parameter, `cipher` structure.
* **T1027 - Obfuscated Files or Information**
* **Justification:** The use of hardcoded buffers (`HARDCODED_BUFFER_72`, `C2_RESPONSE_PAYLOAD`) and a hardcoded XOR constant (`0xB103F154`) to initialize the cipher's state can be considered a form of obfuscation. These values are not immediately obvious as standard Blowfish initialization vectors or S-box values, making static analysis harder without knowing the full context. The `C2_RESPONSE_PAYLOAD` name suggests it might be an embedded encrypted payload or data that needs to be decrypted/processed.
* **Evidence:** `qmemcpy(cipher->P, &HARDCODED_BUFFER_72, sizeof(cipher->P));`, `*s++ = *srcForS++ ^ 0xB103F154;`, `*p++ ^= k ^ 0xB103F154;`.
### 5. Obfuscation or Evasion Techniques
* **Hardcoded Constants/Buffers:** The use of `HARDCODED_BUFFER_72`, `C2_RESPONSE_PAYLOAD`, and the XOR constant `0xB103F154` makes it harder for automated tools or quick manual analysis to immediately identify the standard Blowfish key schedule. These values are embedded within the binary, requiring extraction and further analysis to understand their role fully.
* **Misleading Function Name:** The function name `mlw_decrypt_payload_with_block_cipher` suggests it performs decryption, but the code primarily implements the *key schedule* (initialization) for the cipher. While this setup is a prerequisite for decryption, the name doesn't precisely describe the function's immediate action, which could be a minor form of obfuscation.
* **Embedded Data:** `C2_RESPONSE_PAYLOAD` being a global variable suggests embedded data that is part of the cipher's initial state. This is a common technique to hide configuration or initial values within the binary.
### 6. Observed Facts vs. Inferred Behavior
**Observed Facts (Directly from code):**
* The function `mlw_decrypt_payload_with_block_cipher` takes a `cipher` structure, a `key` pointer, and `keyLen` as input.
* It initializes `cipher->P` with data from `HARDCODED_BUFFER_72`.
* It initializes `cipher->S` (S-boxes) using data from `C2_RESPONSE_PAYLOAD` XORed with `0xB103F154`.
* It processes the input `key` (capped at 56 bytes) to modify the P-array entries, also XORing with `0xB103F154`.
* It repeatedly calls a function named `blowfish::round` on a zero 64-bit block.
* The output of `blowfish::round` is used to update the P-array and then the S-boxes.
* The P-array has 18 `DWORD` entries, and there are 4 S-boxes, each with 256 `DWORD` entries.
**Inferred Behavior (Reasoning based on observations):**
* The code implements the **key schedule for the Blowfish block cipher**.
* `HARDCODED_BUFFER_72` and `C2_RESPONSE_PAYLOAD` are likely initial values for the Blowfish P-array and S-boxes, respectively, embedded within the malware binary.
* The `cipher` structure holds the state (P-array and S-boxes) for a Blowfish instance.
* The malware uses Blowfish for symmetric encryption/decryption of data.
* The name `C2_RESPONSE_PAYLOAD` suggests that the malware communicates with a Command and Control (C2) server, and this buffer might be related to processing C2 responses or containing initial C2-related data.
* The function is a setup routine for the Blowfish cipher, preparing it for subsequent encryption or decryption operations.
* The use of hardcoded buffers and XOR constants serves as a basic obfuscation technique to hide the cipher's initial state.
{
"understanding_point": "Blowfish",
"full_evaluation": "The understanding point is simply 'Blowfish', referring to the identification of the Blowfish cipher. The candidate summary extensively and explicitly identifies the Blowfish block cipher throughout. It states the function implements the key schedule for the Blowfish symmetric block cipher, references blowfish::round, the 18-DWORD P-array, four 256-entry S-boxes, key length capping at 56 bytes, and the zero-block encryption hallmark. This clearly states the point.",
"explanation": "The summary repeatedly and explicitly identifies the Blowfish cipher and its characteristic structures, fully satisfying the understanding point.",
"evidence": "Blowfish Block Cipher: The code implements the key schedule for the Blowfish symmetric block cipher.",
"support_strength": 3,
"satisfied": "true"
}
{
"understanding_point": "Blowfish",
"full_evaluation": "The candidate summary explicitly and repeatedly mentions \"Blowfish\" throughout its analysis. It identifies the function as initializing the internal state of a \"Blowfish cipher structure\" and performing the \"key schedule for the Blowfish algorithm.\" It also details specific characteristics like the P-array (18 DWORDs) and S-boxes (four 256-entry DWORD arrays), the `blowfish::round` function call, and key length handling (up to 56 bytes), all of which are hallmarks of the Blowfish algorithm. The summary leaves no ambiguity about the presence and use of Blowfish.",
"explanation": "The summary explicitly states and provides detailed evidence for the presence and implementation of the Blowfish block cipher, including specific structural and algorithmic details unique to Blowfish.",
"evidence": "The code implements the key schedule for the Blowfish symmetric block cipher. This is evident from: The explicit call to `blowfish::round`. The structure of the P-array (18 `DWORD`s) and S-boxes (four 256-entry `DWORD` arrays). The iterative process of updating the P-array and S-boxes by encrypting a zero block and using the output, which is a hallmark of the Blowfish key schedule. The key length handling (up to 56 bytes).",
"support_strength": 3,
"satisfied": "true"
}
{
"understanding_point": "Blowfish",
"full_evaluation": "The candidate summary clearly and repeatedly identifies the algorithm as Blowfish. It states that the function initializes the P-array and S-boxes of a Blowfish cipher structure, describes the key schedule for the Blowfish algorithm, and explicitly lists \"Blowfish Block Cipher\" under well-known algorithms. There is no contradiction or ambiguity regarding this point; the summary directly names Blowfish and explains supporting characteristics such as 18 P-array entries, four 256-entry S-boxes, key length up to 56 bytes, and calls to blowfish::round.",
"explanation": "The summary directly states that the code implements the Blowfish block cipher/key schedule. This fully satisfies the understanding point.",
"evidence": "\"The code implements the key schedule for the Blowfish symmetric block cipher.\"",
"support_strength": 3,
"satisfied": "true"
}